McMINUTES VIDEO: When was the last time ANYONE saw Madeleine? (Apart from T9)

I think it comes as quite a shock to many to realise that these are the only known witnesses to claim to have seen Madeleine during the holiday (to the best of my knowledge and a few years of research..apart from one that appeared about a year ago)



More info and statements here:

Did anyone see Madeleine during the holiday?

http://forum2.aimoo.com/MadeleineMcCann/DIscrepancies-by-Topic/Did-anyone-see-Madeleine-during-the-holiday-1-1175171.html


I have several research threads on this subject and a couple of years ago, compiled a set of graphics highlighting the nannies statement portions referring to Madeleine.








I have not spent time trying to prove Madeleine was not seen during the holiday...After tremendous research I have not yet found proof that she WAS seen during the holiday (after Sunday lunchtime)

Was she mistaken for another tapas child?

I've reversed the b&w photo to the same angle as the colour and it shows some anomalies to the colour.
The nose appears slightly longer and the nostrils more flared on the b&w.
It may be the angle of the head, but there is a question in my mind that the ears are different in the two photos.
I do have some reservations as to why anyone would take a colour photograph and convert it to b&w, for imo that is what this is.

Is the black and white photograph really Madeleine?

malena stool wrote:

I've reversed the b&w photo to the same angle as the colour and it shows some anomalies to the colour.
The nose appears slightly longer and the nostrils more flared on the b&w.
It may be the angle of the head, but there is a question in my mind that the ears are different in the two photos.
I do have some reservations as to why anyone would take a colour photograph and convert it to b&w, for imo that is what this is.

Is the black and white photograph really Madeleine?

The black and white one isn't Madeleine. I'm sure someone will recall who it is. I can't for the moment. Maybe one of Jane Tanner's children?

The black and white photo is of the Paynes daughter.

It highlights how easily it would be for people (prior to the disappearance) to mistake the tapas children for Madeleine when shown the younger picture of Madeleine.

malena stool wrote:

I've reversed the b&w photo to the same angle as the colour and it shows some anomalies to the colour.
The nose appears slightly longer and the nostrils more flared on the b&w.
It may be the angle of the head, but there is a question in my mind that the ears are different in the two photos.
I do have some reservations as to why anyone would take a colour photograph and convert it to b&w, for imo that is what this is.

Is the black and white photograph really Madeleine?

That is the point of showing the photos - the black and white photo is not of Madeleine at all. Is is supposedly of one of the Paynes daughters. However, the similarities at first glance are remarkable (imo), therefore, it is very possible others in PDL at the time could have also glanced at the Payne girl and thought it to be Madeleine.

HiDeHo wrote:The black and white photo is of the Paynes daughter.

It highlights how easily it would be for people (prior to the disappearance) to mistake the tapas children for Madeleine when shown the younger picture of Madeleine.

Sorry HiDeHo - our posts crossed.

There are many accounts that are OBVIOUSLY mistaken.

Maria the tapas cook claims to have seen Madeleine every day as she saw her in the creche next t the tapas. Madeleine went to another creche 10 minutes away, so she MAY have been mistaking the Paynes daughter who went there.

Miguuel Matias (or an employee who showed him the CCTV footage) was CONVINCED that Madeleine was in the footage dancing with her dad.

We know that Madeleine wasn't there so that tells me that one of the other T7 children looked VERY similar and (as I recall reading) continued to believe it was Madeleine even after being corrected!

Some witnesses claim that Madeleine stood out as she was very shy...in fact, many of the OC staff claimed she was shy as can be seen in the 'Personality graphics'

As with the nannies (which , to keep the video as easy to view as poss) I could not find one nanny that was entirely specific that it was Madeleine. Some claimed the parents picked her up on days that the records show it was the other. The twins nany claims to have seen Madeleine ONCE (day unknown),

I am not looking to prove Madeleine was NOT seen during the holiday but I cannot find ONE witness statement that proves she WAS.

This is the statement that inspired the video..

Mark Harrison Reports on CADAVER dog searches.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic30.html

Mark Warner Creche at Praia Da Luz.

This is the location of the last confirmed sighting by a person independent of family members of Madeleine McCann. Although this location was within the original search area it may well benefit from a further search using enhanced detecting methods for human remains. This will depend on the size of any outside grounds and concealed areas inside the building.

It tells me that Madeleine was NOT at high tea as they arranged the dogs to check the last CONFIRMED location which was the creche. Had she been seen at High Tea there would be no logic to check the creche.