Missing Madeleine
Come join us...there's more inside you cannot see as a guest!

Join the forum, it's quick and easy

Missing Madeleine
Come join us...there's more inside you cannot see as a guest!
Missing Madeleine
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

+5
saloongirl
comperedna
jassi
interested
Karen
9 posters

Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  Karen Thu 2 Apr - 14:16



Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

A former German detective with years of experience working on murder investigations has added his voice to the legions of people backing disgraced Madeleine cop Gonçalo Amaral.

Ulrich Merz, 60, was in Praia da Luz on the day Madeleine went missing in 2007. He has been following the various investigations ever since with the eye of a trained professional.

His “exasperation” at the way things have been handled down the years is one of the reasons for his decision to put pen to paper.

He writes to Amaral as the latter waits on tenterhooks to hear the judge’s final decision over whether or not he is liable for the €1.2 million defamation claim taken out against him by Madeleine’s parents five years ago.

Merz does not mince his words. Amaral’s theory, given the details available at the time, was “completely valid”, he tells the policeman.

The theory that burglars could have abducted Madeleine simply “does not fit the profile”, he claims - and indeed, in his opinion as a criminal investigator, Merz does “not believe in an abduction” at all.

Social media support for Amaral since he was “disgraced” - particularly by the British media - and removed from the original Portuguese investigation has been resounding, but this is perhaps the first time a trained police investigator has come out on record in this way.

Non-English speaking, Merz is unconcerned.

He claims the case is unique in that the Portuguese government “has allowed itself to be pushed around” by Britain, currently conducting the “Operation Grange” investigation into Madeleine’s almost eight-year-old disappearance.

“The way this case has been handled is particularly unique because your conclusions differed from those of the British government,” he told Amaral, stressing his “exasperation” at seeing a fellow policeman’s work “denigrated”.

The Resident learnt of Merz’ letter as it was handed to us to pass on to Amaral. We cannot go into the details of Merz’ theory as a criminal investigator with specific experience in murder cases as it would undoubtedly see us in legal hot-water.

As Portuguese news media has long pointed out, Amaral’s theory, expounded in his book “The Truth of the Lie”, has seen him financially-strapped since its publication.

Bank accounts have been frozen, the book ‘seized’ and withdrawn from sale for months, and his “civil position”, as the former detective refers to it, made untenable.

In an open letter to his supporters as the long-running trial for defamation came to a close, Amaral reiterated his belief that the parents of the missing child have “sought to ‘asphyxiate’ him financially and push him to a civil death” - a position from which he would be “unable to react judicially”.

“After five years, the parents of the child that mysteriously disappeared on the 3rd of May of 2007 in the Algarve were not able to fully achieve what they intended. I am alive, I'm able to financially sustain the civil suit, although not much more than that…”

Since that message, Projecto Justiça Gonçalo Amaral has issued a new bulletin saying the judge’s decision on the McCann parents’ suit should come after the judicial holidays which close on April 6.

“We trust in justice and serenely await the judge’s decision,” the message came to its close.

“God’s windmills move slowly,” Merz concluded in his letter to Amaral. “You are in a trap made by bad people, but I know that when someone shares the knowledge of the deed, the conscience always come out - even if it is unintentional.
“I have strong hope in your complete recovery and rehabilitation,” he tells the Portuguese “colleague” whom he has never met.

Endless column inches have been devoted to this eternal mystery but the truth is that Gonçalo Amaral has been fighting for his professional credibility in an arena bereft of mainstream support.

It is this reality that prompted Ulrich Merz’ hand-written letter which comes in the wake of rumblings from the UK that the Metropolitan Police may at last be considering a renewed scale back of the multi-million pound investigation into Madeleine’s disappearance.

By NATASHA DONN natasha.donn@algarveresident.com
Karen
Karen
Golden Poster
Golden Poster

Female
Number of posts : 635
Location : The Netherlands
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2010-03-26

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  interested Thu 2 Apr - 14:55

I don't recall any UK policeman (or "ex") publicly supporting Mr. Amaral's conclusions despite seeing references years ago by posters that some said they should be charged even "with less evidence than that".
interested
interested
Platinum Poster
Platinum Poster

Number of posts : 2839
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2011-10-22

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  jassi Thu 2 Apr - 15:13

interested wrote:I don't recall any UK policeman (or "ex") publicly supporting Mr. Amaral's conclusions despite seeing references years ago by posters that some said they should be charged even "with less evidence than that".


More than their jobs worth to do that, whatever they might think privately Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop 294124
jassi
jassi
Golden Poster
Golden Poster

Number of posts : 911
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2009-08-21

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  Guest Thu 2 Apr - 15:50

jassi wrote:
interested wrote:I don't recall any UK policeman (or "ex") publicly supporting Mr. Amaral's conclusions despite seeing references years ago by posters that some said they should be charged even "with less evidence than that".


More than their jobs worth to do that, whatever they might think  privately Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop 294124

probably quite close to the truth.

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop 608891
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  comperedna Thu 2 Apr - 17:43

Just to say I really like your little scampering terrier and some of your non-sarcastic constructive comments Marky. That was not meant to be patronising in any way... just appreciative.
comperedna
comperedna
Golden Poster
Golden Poster

Number of posts : 865
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2009-08-24

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  saloongirl Thu 2 Apr - 18:21

I have a friend in the West Midlands police and neither him or any of his colleagues that he's spoken to about the case believe Madeleine was abducted.
saloongirl
saloongirl
Golden Poster
Golden Poster

Female
Number of posts : 757
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2009-08-22

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  frencheuropean Thu 2 Apr - 18:53

http://portugalresident.com/ex-detective-adds-his-voice-to-the-legions-backing-disgraced-maddie-cop

Merci Karen. Someone, at least, courageous enough to voice his opinion and a newspaper ( not British, don't dream) printing it.
A mysterious part though:

"The Resident learnt of Merz’ letter as it was handed to us to pass on to Amaral. We cannot go into the details of Merz’ theory as a criminal investigator with specific experience in murder cases as it would undoubtedly see us in legal hot-water." ?
frencheuropean
frencheuropean
Platinum Poster
Platinum Poster

Number of posts : 1203
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2009-11-02

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  Guest Thu 2 Apr - 19:31

comperedna wrote:Just to say I really like your little scampering terrier and some of your non-sarcastic constructive comments Marky. That was not meant to be patronising in any way... just appreciative.

accepted and appreciated.

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop 608891
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  Lioned Thu 2 Apr - 22:06

Marky wrote:
comperedna wrote:Just to say I really like your little scampering terrier and some of your non-sarcastic constructive comments Marky. That was not meant to be patronising in any way... just appreciative.

accepted and appreciated.

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop 608891

Blimey ! You got a friend at last.The power of the scampering dog !

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop 25346
Lioned
Lioned
Platinum Poster
Platinum Poster

Number of posts : 8554
Age : 115
Location : Down South
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2009-08-30

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  Krisy22 Thu 2 Apr - 22:59

Marky wrote:
comperedna wrote:Just to say I really like your little scampering terrier and some of your non-sarcastic constructive comments Marky. That was not meant to be patronising in any way... just appreciative.

accepted and appreciated.

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop 608891


Yay ... and love the dog. Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop 294124
Krisy22
Krisy22
Platinum Poster
Platinum Poster

Female
Number of posts : 3382
Location : good old Oxfordshire no goats... lots of RAIN....
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2008-07-27

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  jinvta Fri 3 Apr - 6:18

frencheuropean wrote:http://portugalresident.com/ex-detective-adds-his-voice-to-the-legions-backing-disgraced-maddie-cop

Merci Karen. Someone, at least, courageous enough to voice his opinion and a newspaper ( not British, don't dream) printing it.
A mysterious part though:

"The Resident learnt of Merz’ letter as it was handed to us to pass on to Amaral. We cannot go into the details of Merz’ theory as a criminal investigator with specific experience in murder cases as it would undoubtedly see us in legal hot-water."   ?

That same sentence caught my eye too. I personally would love to hear Merz's theory, and expect that it is not too far off from Amaral's.

Anyone who has an ounce of common sense knows that the bungled burglary theory is not credible.

I also like how the article defined "disgraced," in that it was not something that Amaral did to become disgraced, but the UK media who disgraced him.
jinvta
jinvta
Platinum Poster
Platinum Poster

Number of posts : 1065
Warning :
Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Left_bar_bleue0 / 1000 / 100Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Right_bar_bleue

Registration date : 2010-01-18

Back to top Go down

Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop Empty Re: Ex-detective adds his voice to the legions backing disgraced Maddie cop

Post  Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum