Panorama:Madeleine:The Last Hope...Thur 3rd May

Panda wrote:

fred wrote:

mumbles wrote:Can't argue the fact that more money has been spent on this one child than any other... but she is still a 'missing child' and as such, the case should never be closed... and I don't believe such cases ever are.

Rightly so.

The case won't be closed, just like the Rui Pedro is still open, even though everyone knows Mario Dias is as guilty as shit.

The PJ said for a long time they would not open the case unless some new evidence is found, this "sighting" came from Spain and the Portugese were quick to say it was not true that the were investigating. By closed , I meant they will stick to their word and only if ever Madeleine is found alive or dead will the case be re-opened.

mumbles wrote:

Panda wrote:

fred wrote:

mumbles wrote:Can't argue the fact that more money has been spent on this one child than any other... but she is still a 'missing child' and as such, the case should never be closed... and I don't believe such cases ever are.

Rightly so.

The case won't be closed, just like the Rui Pedro is still open, even though everyone knows Mario Dias is as guilty as shit.

The PJ said for a long time they would not open the case unless some new evidence is found, this "sighting" came from Spain and the Portugese were quick to say it was not true that the were investigating. By closed , I meant they will stick to their word and only if ever Madeleine is found alive or dead will the case be re-opened.

The case is shelved... not closed. (technically speaking)

When did they say that they would only re-open the case if a body was found? (alive or dead)

I was under the impression that if 'new evidence' was found it would lead to a new investigation.

mumbles wrote:

Panda wrote:

fred wrote:

mumbles wrote:Can't argue the fact that more money has been spent on this one child than any other... but she is still a 'missing child' and as such, the case should never be closed... and I don't believe such cases ever are.

Rightly so.

The case won't be closed, just like the Rui Pedro is still open, even though everyone knows Mario Dias is as guilty as shit.

The PJ said for a long time they would not open the case unless some new evidence is found, this "sighting" came from Spain and the Portugese were quick to say it was not true that the were investigating. By closed , I meant they will stick to their word and only if ever Madeleine is found alive or dead will the case be re-opened.

The case is shelved... not closed. (technically speaking)

When did they say that they would only re-open the case if a body was found? (alive or dead)

I was under the impression that if 'new evidence' was found it would lead to a new investigation.

Panda wrote:

mumbles wrote:

Panda wrote:

fred wrote:

mumbles wrote:Can't argue the fact that more money has been spent on this one child than any other... but she is still a 'missing child' and as such, the case should never be closed... and I don't believe such cases ever are.

Rightly so.

The case won't be closed, just like the Rui Pedro is still open, even though everyone knows Mario Dias is as guilty as shit.

The PJ said for a long time they would not open the case unless some new evidence is found, this "sighting" came from Spain and the Portugese were quick to say it was not true that the were investigating. By closed , I meant they will stick to their word and only if ever Madeleine is found alive or dead will the case be re-opened.

The case is shelved... not closed. (technically speaking)

When did they say that they would only re-open the case if a body was found? (alive or dead)

I was under the impression that if 'new evidence' was found it would lead to a new investigation.

I never said the PJ said that, it was my interpretation of the only way the case would be re-opened

The first year the McCanns were doing the rounds on 3rd May, they attended a BBC T.V. Programme about missing children . One of the Women they spoke to said her 3 yr old sister had gone missing from a supermarket in Germany. This woman was by now over 20 yrs older but still believed she would meet her Sister one day. Coincidentally, yesterday I read that the Father of the missing child wants the U.K.Police to look for his long lost daughter and
his Demand is as a direct consequence of seeing how much help the McCanns have received.

I meant they will stick to their word and only if ever Madeleine is found alive or dead will the case be re-opened.

fred wrote:

mumbles wrote:

Panda wrote:

fred wrote:

mumbles wrote:Can't argue the fact that more money has been spent on this one child than any other... but she is still a 'missing child' and as such, the case should never be closed... and I don't believe such cases ever are.

Rightly so.

The case won't be closed, just like the Rui Pedro is still open, even though everyone knows Mario Dias is as guilty as shit.

The PJ said for a long time they would not open the case unless some new evidence is found, this "sighting" came from Spain and the Portugese were quick to say it was not true that the were investigating. By closed , I meant they will stick to their word and only if ever Madeleine is found alive or dead will the case be re-opened.

The case is shelved... not closed. (technically speaking)

When did they say that they would only re-open the case if a body was found? (alive or dead)

I was under the impression that if 'new evidence' was found it would lead to a new investigation.

~

That's my impression too. In fact the Mccanns could request the re-opening at any time they wanted!

mumbles wrote:

Panda wrote:

mumbles wrote:

Panda wrote:

fred wrote:

The case won't be closed, just like the Rui Pedro is still open, even though everyone knows Mario Dias is as guilty as shit.

The PJ said for a long time they would not open the case unless some new evidence is found, this "sighting" came from Spain and the Portugese were quick to say it was not true that the were investigating. By closed , I meant they will stick to their word and only if ever Madeleine is found alive or dead will the case be re-opened.

The case is shelved... not closed. (technically speaking)

When did they say that they would only re-open the case if a body was found? (alive or dead)

I was under the impression that if 'new evidence' was found it would lead to a new investigation.

I never said the PJ said that, it was my interpretation of the only way the case would be re-opened

The first year the McCanns were doing the rounds on 3rd May, they attended a BBC T.V. Programme about missing children . One of the Women they spoke to said her 3 yr old sister had gone missing from a supermarket in Germany. This woman was by now over 20 yrs older but still believed she would meet her Sister one day. Coincidentally, yesterday I read that the Father of the missing child wants the U.K.Police to look for his long lost daughter and
his Demand is as a direct consequence of seeing how much help the McCanns have received.

I meant they will stick to their word and only if ever Madeleine is found alive or dead will the case be re-opened.

That suggests to me you are saying the PJ said that.

The first year the McCanns were doing the rounds on 3rd May, they attended a BBC T.V. Programme about missing children . One of the Women they spoke to said her 3 yr old sister had gone missing from a supermarket in Germany. This woman was by now over 20 yrs older but still believed she would meet her Sister one day. Coincidentally, yesterday I read that the Father of the missing child wants the U.K.Police to look for his long lost daughter and his Demand is as a direct consequence of seeing how much help the McCanns have received.

Panda wrote:

Go to Missing Children and read the case of Katrice and how her Father is demanding her disappearance be reopened as a direct result of the Mccanns.

I don't subscribe to the theory the case can be re-opened at will, the PJ have said it would only happen if a positive lead about what happened to
Madeleine is obtained. After 5 years it is looking distinctly unlikely......Katrice has been missing over 20 years.

mumbles wrote:

Panda wrote:

Go to Missing Children and read the case of Katrice and how her Father is demanding her disappearance be reopened as a direct result of the Mccanns.

I don't subscribe to the theory the case can be re-opened at will, the PJ have said it would only happen if a positive lead about what happened to
Madeleine is obtained. After 5 years it is looking distinctly unlikely......Katrice has been missing over 20 years.

Panda, I don't need to go and read your thread about missing Katrice as I am already familiar with the story.

AnnaEsse wrote:

mumbles wrote:

Panda wrote:

Go to Missing Children and read the case of Katrice and how her Father is demanding her disappearance be reopened as a direct result of the Mccanns.

I don't subscribe to the theory the case can be re-opened at will, the PJ have said it would only happen if a positive lead about what happened to
Madeleine is obtained. After 5 years it is looking distinctly unlikely......Katrice has been missing over 20 years.

Panda, I don't need to go and read your thread about missing Katrice as I am already familiar with the story.

Panda has posted an article published today, which you may not have read.

mumbles wrote:Panda :

The first year the McCanns were doing the rounds on 3rd May, they attended a BBC T.V. Programme about missing children . One of the Women they spoke to said her 3 yr old sister had gone missing from a supermarket in Germany. This woman was by now over 20 yrs older but still believed she would meet her Sister one day. Coincidentally, yesterday I read that the Father of the missing child wants the U.K.Police to look for his long lost daughter and his Demand is as a direct consequence of seeing how much help the McCanns have received.

Yes, I'm familiar to both of those stories... but what have they to do with your claim that the Portuguese said that the case will only be re-opened if Madeleine is found either dead or alive?

Panda wrote:

mumbles wrote:Panda :

The first year the McCanns were doing the rounds on 3rd May, they attended a BBC T.V. Programme about missing children . One of the Women they spoke to said her 3 yr old sister had gone missing from a supermarket in Germany. This woman was by now over 20 yrs older but still believed she would meet her Sister one day. Coincidentally, yesterday I read that the Father of the missing child wants the U.K.Police to look for his long lost daughter and his Demand is as a direct consequence of seeing how much help the McCanns have received.

Yes, I'm familiar to both of those stories... but what have they to do with your claim that the Portuguese said that the case will only be re-opened if Madeleine is found either dead or alive?

For the SECOND time, I said it was my opinion that the case would only be opened if Madeleine was found dead or alive. It makes sense because the PJ have said they would only re-open the case if there was a definite reason .

the slave wrote:It's all going MENTAL on the Panorama page!!!
Mental.
Two rabid McCann fans against the rest of us.
It's mental .
Gaspar Statements ....THE LOT.

pennylane wrote:

the slave wrote:It's all going MENTAL on the Panorama page!!!
Mental.
Two rabid McCann fans against the rest of us.
It's mental .
Gaspar Statements ....THE LOT.

It's been like that all day.... and the staunch defenders of child neglect, have been resorting to their usual name calling tactics - in an attempt to get it all whooshed.

Methinks there's nobody manning the decks there at the BEEB. Well today is Sunday after all

To bad for the gruesome twosome and their pink mouthpiece, because it's ALL there and then some.

tigger wrote:

pennylane wrote:

the slave wrote:It's all going MENTAL on the Panorama page!!!
Mental.
Two rabid McCann fans against the rest of us.
It's mental .
Gaspar Statements ....THE LOT.

It's been like that all day.... and the staunch defenders of child neglect, have been resorting to their usual name calling tactics - in an attempt to get it all whooshed.

Methinks there's nobody manning the decks there at the BEEB. Well today is Sunday after all

To bad for the gruesome twosome and their pink mouthpiece, because it's ALL there and then some.

It's all going to be whooshed tomorrow, just read that Radio Times has nothing to do with BBC - so office is closed for the weekend? Shock, horror tomorrow when the editor logs on?

mossman wrote:Geez louise, how entertaining it is over there. I must confess to never having visited "the other side" and do not intend to start now, but goodness me I have never read the likes of it. Are they serious in what they say. If the subject matter were not so sad, it would make a great comedy.